Three reflections on today’s march (or why I didn’t join in)

I didn’t take part in the People’s Vote (PV) march. Nor have I signed the petition to revoke Article 50. In previous months, I have outlined problems which I have with this campaign, including its lack of respect for the original referendum result and increasingly illiberal character. Here are three observations which are more specific to events this weekend.

1/ Marching/signing the petition makes no deal more likely

I continue to be troubled by the PV campaign’s rejection of the May Withdrawal Agreement. I don’t think that PV supporters appreciate the remote odds which they face and associated risks of no deal. If the May Agreement is rejected, let us say that the chances of a second referendum and no deal both stand at 50%. In a subsequent referendum with a three-way choice (remain, no deal, May agreement), let us say that each option has a 33% chance of victory. This simplifies things somewhat, yet illustrates the long odds faced by the PV campaign. In this scenario, there is a 1 in 6 chance of Britain remaining in the EU; the no deal outcome has a much higher chance of success.

I am unimpressed by a campaign which courts disaster like this. In my opinion, acceptance of the May agreement by parliament is the best course of action. This agreement avoids no deal and respects the result of the first referendum. Given that it provides no clear victory to any side, I also believe that the May agreement is most likely to promote national reconciliation.

2/ The PV campaign exhibits symptoms of alt-centrism

In recent times, I have been alarmed by the changing character of European centrism. In the three countries I follow most closely (UK, Spain and Poland), centrists have become distinguished by their partisanship, disdain for liberal-democratic procedure and illiberal online organization. In contexts in which liberals are locked out of governments – a counter-case is France – this seems to be an established trend. I do not consider movements like PV, Ciudadanos and KOD to be equivalent to the alt-right/left, but the label ‘alt-centrist’ is apposite; these movements have strayed from classic centrism.

Developments over the last few days confirm my worries about the PV campaign. The notion that an online petition overrides a statutory referendum is absurd, yet is seriously entertained by Twitter accounts sympathetic to PV. Not everyone who marched today adopts such views, yet I fear that this kind of disposition is not untypical.

3/ The PV campaign embodies failures of UK liberal society

In most Western countries, the populist challenge to liberalism reflects failures of the latter; much has been written about the influence of stagnant real wages, inequality, immigration etc. These phenomena have taken place across countries, yet there is a specific issue with UK liberalism: the failure to mobilize during the 2016 referendum.

I am afraid that impressive levels of participation in today’s march throw into relief poor participation in the 2016 Remain campaign. During this campaign, I was one of the most active Remain campaigners in Wales. I was repeatedly disappointed by desultory engagement of fellow Remainers; I lost count of the number of occasions in which ‘major’ Cardiff leafleting sessions were attended by just a handful of volunteers. If the UK Remain campaign had been one million volunteers strong, à la today’s march, I suspect that we would have won the referendum. The fact that UK liberal society achieved such impressive mobilization today, for a cause which risks aggravating the country’s plight, is a source of no small personal irritation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: